Ok, I fixed the "problem".
I knew something didn't look right. Whenever I create a new partition or format, I'm used to exploring the drive and seeing nothing, and at most maybe a "cloudy" folder (hidden). But this RECYCLER folder was as yellow/gold(non hidden) as it gets. It wasn't a hidden file and it wasn't a system file. I believe it was the real recycler folder, the attributes were just funky. It had something to do with Norton Protected Recycle Bin(Norton Antivirus 2005). I disabled that feature on all the drives, booted in safe mode, did a quick format on the drive, rebooted, and now the RECYCLER folder is a hidden/system folder. So you can't see it with "Show hidden Files" enabled, but if you uncheck "Hide Protected System Files" you can see it. Thank you for your help.